Last month, Home Depot and Menards found themselves in class action lawsuits, each from the same legal office in Chicago. Their crime?
The plaintiffs in each case state that the companies are profiting from false advertising regarding lumber dimensions.
So are they?
Well, yes and no.
Yes, because a standard 4x4 or 2x4 is not, in fact, actually four inches by four inches or two inches by four inches. What most people think of as a 4x4 is really measured at three and a half inches by three and a half inches. These are the nominal measurements, which mean the numbers fit within a scale that will then be identified as part of a larger label. Nominal measurements are used in classifying data, or in this case, classifying lumber.
To simplify, think of a 4x4 as a name, rather than a measurement. It represents a label, the same way we know yellow popsicles to be banana or red popsicles to be cherry. Whether or not those fruits are actually in the treats is irrelevant; the label isn't a literal description, but a way we identify one from another.
So in that case, home improvement stores have been lying to their customers, right? Not exactly.
The same way a grocery store isn't expected to post disclaimers on every popsicle deception, lumber retailers aren't usually required to give warnings for their nominal labels. Why? Because just like we assume most moms know better than to expect real fruit in their popsicles, most professional woodworkers know that lumber is described in nominal, rather than actual, measurements.
People that aren't familiar with trade names aren't out of luck, though. Because you are still receiving the standard industry size, most projects expect those missing half inches and accommodate. To buy lumber that was cut in actual sizes, you may have more trouble finding equipment or DIY plans that match your raw materials.
So what can lumber providers do to make sure customers know what they're getting? Millwood's stance is one of openness and transparency. We use nominal sizes like anyone else in the wood industry, but communicating that information to new customers is high priority. That's why we utilize programs like PDS (Pallet Design System) to help us better explain what customers are buying.
Are you someone that knew about nominal sizes, or are you shocked to discover the difference? Let us know in the comments!